However, any look at the evidence shows that the amount of democracy is not as high as it could, or should, be and the quality is abysmal. Like, really, really bad.
When it comes to all the problems and injustices in our country and in the world at large people love to argue and discuss about what policy or what politician/CEO caused the problem or is failing to do something about it. However, it is sort of crazy to think that swapping out a president or passing a single law will fix the country or save the world. Individuals could help, but most people would agree that in recent years most new hopefuls on both sides really fail to make the strides we hope of them, in fact they tend to just end up supporting the problem we hoped they would alleviate. This is largely due to a neoliberal ideology shared by the elite which enforces the established power structure (ie. de-regulate the wealthy and powerful minority, oppress and further impoverish the weak majority). And as we know, this has lead us to many of the terrible conditions we see today from war in the middle east in the name of oil, GMOs being used nearly world wide despite the environmental and health risks, the destruction of vital rain forests around the world, the polluting and killing of the oceans, fracking and the like persisting in countries where it poisons water and causes earthquakes, and a massive nuclear proliferation that many analysts claim to be the number one threat to the global human population next to, the last in my incomplete list, the catastrophe of climate change . Its a good thing I have a solution that I really believe could fix all theses problems! Its radical, so you’ll have to stay with me here, please don’t unsubscribe from my blog because you think I’m some sort of crazy person, but I think democracy is the solution.
Surprise surprise, democracy of all things. Do you remember learning about it in school? I do. I was taught that we (in the USA) have the greatest democracy on the planet. That’s still the argument I hear from a lot of people today! I don’t think it’s true, but even if it was true, just because something is the best does not mean that it isn’t actually terrible. If you have 10 broken down rusting cars in a junk yard but one of them has chrome rims or something then you could pick it out and call it the best. However, its still just a broken down rusting car in a junk yard. That car with the chrome rims, that’s American democracy. Keeping with the analogy, I tend to think that once a car doesn’t run anymore it is not really a car, but a hunk of scrap metal, right? If it loses its fundamental function then it loses the justification for calling it a car. Like, call it a car by form then, sure, but there are plenty of other justified things to call it now that denote its brokenness and worthlessness. The point is that we are not living in a democracy! We have some ideas about democracy, and we have even implemented some of them, but there is a lot that would need to change before we could call our current system a democracy of the people.
So, what we, more or less, know to be the best system of making decisions and solving problems is democracy. (If you disagree, I would love to hear about it in the comments section.) The more we have, and the higher quality of it, the better it works. Unfortunately in the world around, the state of democracy is not great where it exists (like a junkyard car), and this is well known and understood by many people. Here I want to focus on the United States, where I see a population who largely seems to believe that our form of democracy works and is OK as is, with a few notable exceptions. However, any look at the evidence shows that the amount of democracy is not as high as it could, or should, be and the quality is abysmal. Like, really, really bad.
We can start by looking at why so many people feel that the government doesn’t work for them and that it instead works for special interests. Because that’s how it actually is.(check the video out!) So now we can see that our government ignores the people of the bottom 90% of wealth, and listens to the top 10%. The government does not represent the people, which sounds very strange for a democracy, right? There is a word for what we have: plutocracy, a government ruled by the rich.
Our government strips our rights from us as a matter of common policy, we know this. So we have groups like the NAACP, Planned Parenthood, ACLU, Human Rights Campaign, and many more. These groups fight to defend our rights and in doing so try to support America’s democracy. That’s right, our condition is such that we need these organizations to try to get some power back to the people of a democracy where the people ostensibly hold the power! In a true democracy these institutions would no longer need to exist. In a democracy the people would be able to, with their collective voices alone, strike down any institution that claimed the authority to take away their rights and freedoms. They would not need any organization to fight for them. Why are ‘rights’ called ‘rights’? Because they are innate, not something to be given or taken away. It is clear that any institution that aims to strip our rights from us is doing so for nefarious reasons. Democracy is a threat to tyranny, and our institutions of power will do everything they can to impede it without destroying the illusion of democracy that grasps the people. (I began my discussion about rights and how our government takes them away from people to subvert democracy in a previous post).
Yes, the key to maintaining this faux-democracy that we currently have is by keeping the people uninformed, scared, and comfortable. Uninformed so they do not know that there really is something terribly wrong, and if they do catch on, so they will not know what to do about it. Scared so that even if they get a sense of something being awry, they fear the repercussions of taking action against it. And comfortable because people who live their lives in privileged comfort will not stand up to destroy the institution who maintains that comfort, no matter how tyrannical or horrific they may understand it to be. Also comfortable because if you are comfortable you do not have the motivation to stand up and fight, your instinct is to stay still and behave in the hopes that they won’t take your comfort away. And it works, to a large extent, unfortunately. But, there will come a time when the natural cycles of the climate and the earth are so irreparably damaged and/or we are so close to the MAD of nuclear annihilation that we will wish that it had been us in charge the whole time instead of the people there now who are willing to bring us to the edge of destruction in the name of greed and power. Suddenly the comfort will be gone, or meaningless, and we will wish we had spoken out, fought to have a real democracy and we will wonder why we didn’t know about this terrible storm brewing until it was already upon us.
I’d like to conclude this post with a series of links where you can go to follow ideas about democracy, how our government is taking it away from us, and what we can do to get it back.
Obviously, DemocracyNow!, they discuss may topics about democracy in the USA and abroad. The Intercept is a brilliant investigative news outlet that practices “adversarial journalism” that challenges the standard narrative of the government in the intention of keeping an informed electorate. Truth Dig is a place to get a deeper analysis of the news, often commenting on themes of democracy (or lack thereof). Tom Dispatch is a fantastic source for alternative view points that counter the main stream narrative. Represent Us is an interesting grass roots action plan to end the corruption in the USA and repair our democracy. The United States has a Green Party that supports action to move us toward a real, healthy, functioning democracy. ROAR Magazine is a leftist publication that largely features essays written by emerging front-line experts in the fields of social movements, war, democracy, human rights, the environment and things like this. And finally, Noam Chomsky who is said to be the world’s greatest political academic and dissident. He has written extensively about democracy, rights, systems of power, corruption, tyrannies, and social movements fighting to take back power. I cannot recommend highly enough that everyone read and listen to Chomsky; you will find him dotted about in many of the sources listed above.
Further, please go to your local bookstores and alternative bookstores for more information! Knowledge = Power = Books
Thank you all for reading, and thank you for continuing to be critical!
Update 1, 6 June 2016: I wanted to include this quote from Chomsky’s new book, Who Rules the World? I think it is relevant to the discussion above.
”
A companion story in the New York Times reports that “two-thirds of Americans support the United States joining a binding international agreement to curb growth of greenhouse gas emissions.” And by a five-to-three margin, Americans regard the climate as more important than the economy. But it doesn’t matter. Public opinion is dismissed. That fact, once again, sends a strong message to Americans. It is their task to cure the dysfunctional political system, in which popular opinion is a marginal factor. The disparity between public opinion and policy, in this case, has significant implications for the fate of the world.
We should, of course, have no illusions about a past “golden age.” Nevertheless, the developments just reviewed constitute significant changes. The undermining of functioning democracy is one of the contributions of the neoliberal assault on the world’s population in the past generation. And this is not happening just in the U.S.; in Europe the impact may be even worse.”